Throughout his career, Weatherholtz was the top arm on the CU pitching staff as he finished his career with the most innings pitched in program history (328.1). He is also tied for second in wins (27), third in career strikeouts (224), tied for third in appearances (59) and seventh in ERA (4.28). Weatherholtz was a vital part of Concord’s two conference championships teams in 2011 and 2013. He won at least seven games in three of his four seasons and tossed 80 or more innings three times. Weatherholtz culminated his career by being named All-MEC First Team in 2014.