Kestner did it all at Concord, playing softball (1999-02), basketball (1998-02) and competing on the track team (2001-02). Kestner was a two-time first team all-conference honoree in softball in 2001 and 2002. As a freshman she ranked second in the nation in triples with nine while her 45 RBI were also the fourth-most in the country. As a basketball standout, Kestner was named to the All-WVIC Tournament Team in 2002 after averaging the most points per game of any player at the event. To top it all off, she also holds CU's shot put record.