Shaar was an All-WVIAC standout three times on the women's basketball team in her career. She made the second team as a sophomore, and earned first team honors as a junior and a senior.

Playing for head coaches Russell Hill and Will Johnson, Shaar scored 1,619 points during her time at Concord, good for fifth on the program’s all-time list. She also grabbed 620 rebounds.

Shaar, who stays active and works as a personal trainer, also played tennis for Concord her junior and senior years.