The architect of two conference championships in a four-year span, Justice sported a record of 40-17 from 2011-15. Justice's first championship team was in 2011 when the Mountain Lions defeated West Virginia Wesleyan in the regular-season finale to claim their first West Virginia Intercollegiate Athletic Conference (WVIAC) Championship since 1990. Three years later, Concord not only won the Mountain East Conference Championship, but also won the Super Region One Championship—the first regional championship team in program history. Justice is the only coach in program history to win a national postseason game as CU went 13-1 and advanced to the NCAA Division II National Semifinals in 2014. Justice was named conference coach of the year twice in his career at CU, and was voted as the Super Region One Coach of the Year in 2014.