Chernutan was a two-time All-Mountain East Conference performer during her time in the Maroon and Gray. Her first All-MEC accolade came in the spring of 2017 when she helped Concord to a win in the 4x400-meter relay at the MEC Championships, leading to an All-MEC First Team selection. During the 2018 outdoor season, the Shady Spring, West Virginia native was named to the All-MEC Honorable Mention Team as the 4x400-meter relay team placed thirda t the MEC Championships.